▲
STOCKUPSIDE.IO
Analyst Price Target Intelligence
← Full Rankings
← Back to rankings
Ranked #2298 by analyst upside · 2026-08-12
AII
American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.
Financial Services · Market Cap $396M · P/E 4.2x
ANALYST PRICE TARGET
+21.3%
implied upside to consensus target
Current Price $20.19
Consensus Target $24.5
Bull Target $26.0
Bear Target $23.0
Analysts Covering 4
ANALYST CONSENSUS - BUY
Strong Buy
3
Buy
1
Hold
1
Sell
0
52-Week Low $16.19
52-Week High $26.36
YTD Return +5.6%
FUNDAMENTALS
Market Cap $396M
P/E Ratio (TTM) 4.2x
Forward P/E 6.7x
EPS (TTM) $4.84
PEG Ratio N/A
Dividend Yield N/A
Revenue (TTM) $296M
Profit Margin 27.6%
52-WEEK RANGE
52-Week Low $16.19
52-Week High $26.36
Current Price $20.19
Bear Target $23.0
Bull Target $26.0
● Now $20.19 ● Target $24.5
TRADING DATA
Avg Volume 126K
YTD Return +5.6%
Analyst Count 4
Consensus Buy
Upside to Target +21.3%
Last Updated 2026-08-12

ANALYST SUMMARY

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. (AII) is currently trading at $20.19 with a Wall Street consensus price target of $24.5, implying potential upside of 21.3% over the next 12 months. 4 analysts currently cover AII, with a consensus rating of Buy - 80% of analysts rate the stock a Buy or Strong Buy. The most bullish analyst has a price target of $26.0, while the most cautious has a target of $23.0.

AII operates in the Financial Services sector with a market capitalisation of $396M. The stock is up 5.6% year-to-date and is currently trading near the lower end of its 52-week range of $16.19 – $26.36.

SIMILAR STOCKS

Other Financial Services stocks with comparable size and valuation.

NEWT +21.8%
NewtekOne, Inc.
$368M · P/E 5.6x · Hold
NPB +19.3%
Northpointe Bancshares, Inc.
$591M · P/E 7.4x · Buy
FRST +14.1%
Primis Financial Corp.
$405M · P/E 7.6x · Buy
VEL +17.9%
Velocity Financial, Inc.
$720M · P/E 6.6x · Buy
AMSF +27.3%
AMERISAFE, Inc.
$519M · P/E 11.3x · Buy

RECENT ANALYST CALLS

Upgrade/downgrade history for AII, with each firm's 90-day track record across all stocks we track. See full firm rankings →

Citizens - Reiterated
Market Outperform → Market Outperform 2026-05-13 Building track record
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods - Reiterated
Outperform → Outperform 2026-04-07 Building track record
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods - Reiterated
Outperform → Outperform 2026-03-09 Building track record
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods - Reiterated
Outperform → Outperform 2025-11-18 Building track record
Citizens - Reiterated
Market Outperform → Market Outperform 2025-11-17 Building track record
JMP Securities - Reiterated
Market Outperform → Market Outperform 2025-10-14 Building track record
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods - Reiterated
Outperform → Outperform 2025-10-06 Building track record
Piper Sandler - Reiterated
Overweight → Overweight 2025-10-06 14% win rate (7 calls)
HISTORICAL SNAPSHOT

Point-in-time data from StockUpside's daily snapshots. Tracks price, analyst target, upside %, consensus, and analyst count.

Loading…
ANALYST CONVICTION SCORE
61
out of 100
Coverage depth
12/30
Consensus clarity
27/30
Vote unanimity
20/25
Rating stability
2/15

Measures analyst agreement, not fundamental quality. A high score means analysts broadly agree on this call - not that the stock will go up.

See 4,000+ stocks ranked by analyst upside

StockUpside.io tracks analyst consensus price targets across thousands of US-listed stocks, updated every day. The full ranked list is available with a Pro subscription.

View Full Rankings →